A discussion on the framers intents when writing the constitution

The relatively lean text, and the fact that it omits mention of particular powers, has no doubt contributed to the constitutional tension, controversy, and occasional crises that have marked American foreign affairs.

James Wilson suggested election by popular vote versus election by state legislature, but his proposal was shot down 10—1 by the delegates.

Instead, he maintained, before the Revolution general power over foreign affairs had been lodged in the British Crown.

Constitutional Convention (United States)

There was a deep worry in the convention's discussions about executive power, epitomized by Edmund Randolph 's characterization of it as the "foetus of monarchy.

In fact even if the representatives are chosen on the basis of the number of States, the Senators hold office in the name of the people and are accountable to the people Black D On the national level, for example, legislators can be chosen from districts that each elect a single representative.

It is best characterized as "conservative activism. No bill could be enacted into law by the king without the advice and consent of both houses of Parliament.

Framers of the Constitution

In the context of foreign affairs, the United States has been marching backward, for the president has largely secured the prerogatives of the English Crown that the Framers denied to him in the Constitutional Convention, and which the nation had roundly condemned since the writing of the Declaration of Independence.

He properly denied the existence of any such ironclad obligation, but his view that the president possessed discretionary authority, as part of his "duty" to preserve peace "till war is declared," triggered a response from Madison, who wrote under the pseudonym of "Helvidius" and asserted that if Washington's proclamation were valid, it meant that the president had usurped congressional power to decide between a state of peace or a state of war.

But that phrase is otherwise employed in the appointment clause to indicate a process that does depend on exclusive and sequential steps: Local papers even said little about the meeting of the Convention. Yet, singularly absent from the text, he, more than anyone, left his imprint on the final document.

According to international law commentators at the time of the founding, a declaration of war was desirable because it announced the institution of a state of war, and the legal consequences it entailed, to the adversary, to neutral nations, and to citizens of the sovereign initiating the war.

Dahl presupposes that this arrangement would make the legislatures more responsive to the needs of property holders. Whatever the method used, public officials in a representative democracy hold office in the name of the people and remain accountable to the people for their actions. The convention's decision to create the supremacy clause was a pivotal move, for the declaration in Article 6 that, "This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States and all Treaties, … shall be the Supreme Law of the land, … any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding," signified the end of "state sovereignty" and enabled the federal government to wrest control of foreign policy from the recalcitrant states.

Provincial and local elections can mirror these national models, or choose their representatives more informally through group consensus instead of elections.

The Constitution

A vocal minority wanted the national executive to be chosen by the governors of the states. The contention, moreover, that the conduct of foreign policy is not restricted by the Constitution is at odds with Madison's statement in Federalist No.

There was nothing in the language of the provision, or in the records of the convention debates, to indicate that the president would assume the dominant role in foreign affairs.

The new language empowered the Senate to modify spending bills proposed by the House. The Articles had created an ineffective national government that lacked coercive power over the states.

He had James Madison in mind in particular. None of these events, however, served the latter purpose so well as two wholly unanticipated events: Writing for a unanimous Court in Inland Waterway Corp.

While the Constitution requires joint action by the president and Senate in making treaties, it is silent on the repository of the authority to terminate treaties. In drafting the Constitution, the difficult job of extracting agreement was accomplished by a process of reduction and removal.

Article 2 of the Constitution gives the president the "power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur.

The Undemocratic Nature Of The American Constitution Essay Sample

Slavery was widespread in the states at the time of the Convention. Bill of Rights Show. Author: National Constitution Center staff. About this Lesson.

The Framers' Constitution

This lesson, which includes a pre-lesson and several post-lesson ideas, is intended to be used in conjunction with the National Constitution Center’s Bill of Rights show. constitution of the united states (–) Delegates sent to Philadelphia from the thirteen states to discuss changes to the existing Confederation government formed.

Framers of the Constitution Fifty-five delegates attended sessions of the Constitutional Convention, and are considered the Framers of the Constitution, although only 39 delegates actually signed. [37] [38] The states had originally appointed 70 representatives to the Convention, but a number of the appointees did not accept or could not attend.

In focusing on the “supermajoritarian political process” as the primary source of the Constitution’s “greatness,” our authors ignore what the framers say about the Constitution. In other words, McGinnis and Rappaport claim to understand the Constitution better than the framers and founders.

A Discussion on the Framers’ Intents When Writing the Constitution ( words, 7 pages) One overriding notion can be derived from literature regarding the framers intent when writing the Constitution this idea being that scholars do not come to a definitive conclusion regarding what the framers meant when they wrote the eighth amendment.

A decade of constitution-writing at the state level had given key founders the opportunity to compare their reading to their experiences. Historian Robert Goldwin observed that by"Americans were the most experienced and accomplished self-governing citizens in the world at the time.

A discussion on the framers intents when writing the constitution
Rated 0/5 based on 6 review
Framers of the Constitution - Essay